"Venkatraman Ns" (via indiaresists Mailing List)
2018-03-22 14:28:58 UTC
India Against Corruption
HOW TO MAKE MPs AND MLAs BEHAVE
Nandini Voice for The Deprived (nandinivoice.com), a Chennai based non
government organization conducted an All India study to ascertain what
people think about the behavior of MPs and MLAs, particularly in the
context of parliament remaining paralysed for more than fourteen days now
and violence in state assemblies with a MLA even going to the extent of
trying to hit others with the mike.The study was conducted by circulating a
message through a few popular blogs and individual communications in
several ways to the attention of cross section of people all over India.
The message conveyed the anguish of Nandini Voice for The Deprived about
several MPs and MLAs stalling the proceedings, rushing to the well,
shouting at the top of their voice even when Prime Minister is speaking and
using abusive language and paralyzing the functions, with total disregard
for presiding officers. People were asked to state their views on the above
deplorable conditions and suggest solutions to find a way out.
Even within three days of circulating the message, number of people
responded from all over India. The highlights of the views and suggestions
expressed are given below.
1. Without exception, every respondent shared the anguish about the present
conditions and stated that the august institutions of parliament and
assemblies have been brought into ridicule by misbehaving MPs and MLAs. In
the process, they are doing tremendous harm to the reputation of India and
Indians all over the world.
2. Most people expressed surprise and shock that the Speaker of Lok Sabha,
Chairman of Rajya Sabha and Speakers in the state assemblies simply allow
the misbehaving MPs and MLAs to get away with their behavior by simply
making oral appeals to them and without taking any effective steps to
impose necessary disciplinary measures and restore the dignity of
parliament and assemblies.
3. Most respondents expressed their frustration and anger but would not
know what they can do when the Speaker of Lok Sabha, Chairman of Rajya
Sabha and Speaker of state assemblies hesitate to exercise their known
powers and residual powers to make the house function smoothly. Respondents
think that simply adjourning the sessions when MPs and MLAs misbehave is no
4. As immediate solution , it was suggested that salaries and perks of all
MPs and MLAs should be totally cut for the entire day, if the session would
not function smoothly for minimum of one hour every day.
5. If more than fifteen hours would be lost due to the interruptions, then
seven days of salary and perks should be cut for every fifteen hours of
6. Some respondents even suggested that marshal should be brought in to
remove the misbehaving members forcefully. But, others said that to start
with, salaries and perks should be cut and then it should be seen whether
situation would improve by this measure, before initiating further remedial
All respondents felt that the ball is now clearly in the court of the
presiding officers and they should act with determination and courage to
restore dignity of the houses. If they would not do so, they would
disappoint the people and make them lose confidence in the process of
democracy as a form of quality governance.
Findings of the study has been submitted to the Speaker of Lok Sabha,
Chairman of Rajya Sabha and President of India for their consideration.
Nandini Voice or The Deprived